Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

Posts Tagged ‘inaccurate’

A friend of mine worked very hard to talk about the problem of debt collectors, credit reports and debt collectors.

If you have be the victim of a debt collector who has lied to you and told you that paying an old debt would improve your credit, or that they could remove the negative information, please contact us.

NO FEE IN YOUR FDCPA OR FCRA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

OUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the FCRA and the FDCPA means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230

DEBT SETTLERS ARE BAD FOR YOU.  DEBT MANAGEMENT PROGRAMS ARE DEBT SETTLEMENT IN DISGUISE.

All references to code sections are courtesy of the Legislative Information System of Virginia, and are provided by leg1.state.va.us.

Debt Management and Debt Settlement is regulated by the Virginia Bureau of Financial Institutions.

Recently, the Oregon Attorney General cracked down on Credit Solutions of America, a debt settler based in Texas.  You can read the story here.

In that story, you will find that CSA has been scamming Oregon consumers for some time. They charge substantial upfront fees and encourage people to default on credit cards so they can afford the upfront fees.

This is also illegal in Virginia, however, the Virginia Attorney General has not yet come down on CSA.

Remember that with debt settlement, there is NO GUARANTEE that it will work.  KCLS does not settle debts, though we have been known to settle lawsuits.

Debt settlers promise that they can settled your debts.  There is no way to promise that truthfully.   No one can promise that a debt will be settled with a creditor, collector, or lawfirm.  There are only 2 ways to not pay for sure 1- Bankruptcy, and 2- win the collection lawsuit.

You can win a collections lawsuit because you do not owe the debt- ie: not yours, or billing errors.

You can win a collection lawsuit for technical reasons- ie: statute of limitations, hearsay, or other evidence problems.

You can also lose a collections lawsuit, even with a debt that is beyond the statute of limitations, with testimony that is based on hearsay, filled with billing errors, where the judge does not follow the law, or the rules of procedure or the rules of evidence.  Even good lawyers can lose in these circumstances.

The most important thing to know is that if you do not try to defend, you cannot win.  You must show up.  Most debt settlers try to settle the debt from afar.  They try to settle, while the collector proceeds to obtain judgment.

There are also some creditors and debt collectors that will not negotiate, and worse yet, when they understand that you have hired a debt settler, will sue, almost immediately, for the simple reason that they believe that the first one to sue will be one of the few to collect anything.  The truth is that this is a self-fulfilling prophesy.

In summary, beware of debt settlers, it is very hard for them to comply with all of the provisions of the Virginia Credit Counseling Act (VCCA), Virginia Code Sections 6.1-363.2 through 6.1-363.26.  Violations of the VCCA can be enforced by consumers who have been duped, pursuant to the Virginia Consumer Protection Act (VCPA), as VCCA specifies at Section 6.1-363.26 that any violation of VCCA is a violation of Section 59.1-200 of the VCPA.

If you have been impacted by anything we mentioned here, you can make an appointment to see us.

NO FEE IN YOUR VCCA/VCPA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

OUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the Virginia Credit Counseling Act and the Virginia Consumer Protection Act means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230

The Fair Credit Reporting Act is designed to protect consumers from inaccurate or outdated information on credit reports.

CONSUMER REPORTING AGENCY REINVESTIGATIONS and The Fair Credit Reporting Act

All references to code sections are courtesy of the Legal Information Institute at Law.Cornell.edu.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires the Credit Reporting Agencies, or Consumer Reporting Agencies to conduct a reinvestigation and the procedures around that reinvestigation.

The section that discusses the requirements for reinvestigation of a disputed item is 15 U.S.C. §1681i.

As usual, we start with the statute.  Please note that we will only be reviewing the section on reinvestigations, so the rest of the section will not be reprinted or discussed.

(5) Treatment of inaccurate or unverifiable information

(A) In general

If, after any reinvestigation under paragraph (1) of any information disputed by a consumer, an item of the information is found to be inaccurate or incomplete or cannot be verified, the consumer reporting agency shall—

(i) promptly delete that item of information from the file of the consumer, or modify that item of information, as appropriate, based on the results of the reinvestigation; and

(ii) promptly notify the furnisher of that information that the information has been modified or deleted from the file of the consumer.

This means that, under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the consumer credit reporting agency must, after reviewing the credit file and information that you provided in conjunction with your request for reinvestigation, must remove the disputed information, if the information cannot be confirmed.

For example- If you have a credit card or perhaps a line of credit with a bank, and the bank reports that you are late one month.  You have proof that you sent payment, and that they cashed your check on or before the due date.

In order to preserve your rights, you must send your dispute to the consumer credit reporting agencies, and provide them with all the information they need to review this account.  If the consumer credit reporting agency cannot verify that the information is accurate, they are required to either delete the information or alternatively, to modify the reporting of the tradeline in the credit file to show that you were not late, and notify the furnisher of the information (your creditor) that they have removed or modified the information in your credit file.  Under a different provision, they are required to have specific procedures to prevent the inaccurate information from reappearing in your credit file.

If the information is accurate, it is proper for the information to remain, so it is important to remember that just because you dispute, and they deal with your dispute incorrectly, does not mean that you have a right to sue.  The Fair Credit Reporting Act is NOT like the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.  They must report inaccurate, or accurate but misleading and incomplete, information in order to have a right to sue at all.

If you have been impacted by anything we mentioned here, you can make an appointment to see us.

NO FEE IN YOUR FCRA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

YOUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the FCRA and the FDCPA means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act is designed to protect consumers from inaccurate or outdated information on credit reports.

CONSUMER REPORTING AGENCY REINVESTIGATIONS and The Fair Credit Reporting Act

All references to code sections are courtesy of the Legal Information Institute at Law.Cornell.edu.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires the Credit Reporting Agencies, or Consumer Reporting Agencies to conduct a reinvestigation and the procedures around that reinvestigation.

The section that discusses the requirements for reinvestigation of a disputed item is 15 U.S.C. §1681i.

As usual, we start with the statute.  Please note that we will only be reviewing the section on reinvestigations, so the rest of the section will not be reprinted or discussed.

(4) Consideration of consumer information

In conducting any reinvestigation under paragraph (1) with respect to disputed information in the file of any consumer, the consumer reporting agency shall review and consider all relevant information submitted by the consumer in the period described in paragraph (1)(A) with respect to such disputed information.

How does this impact you?

The Consumer Credit Reporting Agencies have a duty to consider the information that you provide them.  That means that if you send them a copy of a judgment order that you do not owe the plaintiff money, they are obligated to consider that information.

That also means that when you send a ID Theft Affidavit, or a police report, they must consider that information.  The ID Theft Affidavit and police report are less reliable, as people make mistakes.  They can have old accounts that they do not remember, and thereby be mistaken, so they logically cannot just take your word for it.  They have to CONSIDER your information.  That means that if you provide a affidavit, or some other document with a comparable signature, they should be comparing the signatures.

This obviously comes into play much more with inaccuracies of the “not mine” type.

However, the incorrect status cases also have this issue.  For example, if the credit card company claims that you were late, or did not get a payment during a certain month, then if you provide a copy of the statement from that month (showing the minimum payment due and the due date) and the cleared check, showing that they got at least the minimum payment, on or before the due date.  With that information, the credit reporting agency has all the information necessary to show that the payment was made on time.  If you only provide a copy of the check, they do not have all, but they do have information they must CONSIDER, so they have to actually investigate.

But how does this play out in reality? Do you think that the Consumer Credit Reporting Agencies consider the information that you provide?

Our experience, and the experience of many courts around the country show that the opposite is true.  In Cushman v. Trans Union Corp, a US 3^rd Circuit Court of Appeals opinion from 1997, the court explained that a Consumer Reporting Agency (in that case, TransUnion) could not merely parrot the information of the creditor who was furnishing the data.  In Apodaca v. Discover, a case from the District of New Mexico, the district court held the same against Equifax.  In Whitesides v. Equifax Credit Information Services, Inc., the court in the Western District of Louisiana followed the same line against Experian.  In Crabill v. Trans Union, LLC, 7^th Circuit Court of Appeals, 2001, again, the court found that Trans Union was “parroting”.

While it is possible that the Consumer Credit Reporting Agency has actually looked at your documents, it is unlikely.

HOWEVER WE MUST STRESS THAT THE INFORMATION MUST BE INACCURATE OR THERE IS NO CASE AT ALL.  A technical violation is not a violation.  See, for example, the case of Deandrade v. Trans Union, LLC, 1^st Circuit Court of Appeals, 2008, in which the consumer had sued his mortgage company under a different statute, to undo his mortgage, claiming there were errors. Before that case was resolved, he sued TransUnion as they continued to report that the mortgage was still due.  Because the underlying case had not been resolved, it was unclear that the consumer had no liability for the mortgage, and therefore, it was reasonable for the Consumer Credit Reporting Agency to continue to report that he owed money, albeit with a notation that the account was disputed.

If you have been impacted by anything we mentioned here, you can make an appointment to see us.

NO FEE IN YOUR FCRA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

OUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the FCRA and the FDCPA means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act is designed to protect consumers from inaccurate or outdated information on credit reports.

MAXIMUM POSSIBLE ACCURACY and The Fair Credit Reporting Act

All references to code sections are courtesy of the Legal Information Institute at Law.Cornell.edu.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act requires the Credit Reporting Agencies, or Consumer Reporting Agencies to have a procedure to assure “maximum possible accuracy”.

The section that discusses the requirements for maintain a credit file is 15 U.S.C. §1681e subsection [b].

As usual, we start with the statute.  Please note that we will only be reviewing the section on maximum possible accuracy, so the rest of the section will not be reprinted or discussed.

(b) Accuracy of report

Whenever a consumer reporting agency prepares a consumer report it shall follow reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy of the information concerning the individual about whom the report relates.

The key term here is that the Fair Credit Reporting Act regulates information that is about you by making it illegal to report inaccurate or outdated information.

So, what is inaccurate?

1. Not your account (you never opened or used the account, etc.)
2. Illegal use of your account (someone charged something to your account but it was not you)
3. Wrong status (Bankrupt, they changed the age of the account, you were never late, etc.)

NOT YOUR ACCOUNT

This comes in 2 major varieties, with some minor variations.

1. Identity theft
2. Mixed credit file

Identity theft is where someone other than you opens an account in your name, using your name, your social security number, your date of birth, but you never see the account, the card, or the money.

Mixed credit file is where your name is similar to someone or your social security number is similar to someone.  In this circumstance, the credit bureaus cannot tell the difference between the 2 of you, so what is on 1 is on both.

ILLEGAL USE OF THE ACCOUNT

This is where you have a credit card with a company, but someone steals your card, and uses that card to purchase things for themselves.  This is classic credit card theft.

Another example is where you have the account, but someone steals the card number, and uses that card number to purchase things for themselves or others.  This is the newer version of credit card theft.

WRONG STATUS

This is the situation of a paid off account that shows that you owe money.

This can also be an account that shows that you were late when you never were.  There are a number of credit card companies that play games, and they might receive the money on the 10^th, when the payment is due, but they don’t process the check until after the 20^th when it is late.  Then they report that you were late, and charge you a late fee.  A secret about me —First Tennessee Bank did this to me in the 80s and 90s, and this is one of the reasons I went into consumer law.  Another example is mortgage companies that do the same thing.

Bankrupt accounts reporting as still due and owing, or charged off.  This is a common problem.

Accounts that are delinquent often go to Debt Collectors.  Sometimes they change the date the account first became delinquent, which is the key date the Credit Reporting Agencies use to determine when the account comes off your credit report.  Most delinquent accounts can only be reported for 7 years, but some can be reported for 10 (for example Bankruptcy) and others can be reported for as long as they are outstanding (for example tax liens). There is no time limit for a good account to be reported.

If you have been damaged by any of these actions, you could be entitled to recover actual damages, attorney fees and costs, and in the right circumstances, punitive damages are available.  Getting to punitive damages is very hard, so we usually tell clients that punitive damages are likely to be limited, if available, in their case.

In each of these cases, the key thing is that the information is inaccurate.  Remember, the Fair Credit Reporting Act can only help fix problems of false, inaccurate information.  If the information is true, you cannot remove that information, no matter how much you might try.

If you have been impacted by anything we mentioned here, you can make an appointment to see us.

NO FEE IN YOUR FCRA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

OUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the FCRA and the FDCPA means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230

KCLS LIMITS THE GEOGRAPHY IN WHICH WE TAKE CASES.

YOU MUST BE A VIRGINIA RESIDENT.

If you are not a Virginia Resident, click here to find a lawyer near you.

The Fair Credit Reporting Act is designed to protect consumers from inaccurate or outdated information on credit reports.

FAIR CREDIT REPORTING ACT BASICS

In this blog entry, we will NOT go into details of what happens or what to do, only the basic outline of what happens and what is supposed to happen when dealing with credit reporting issues under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).  It is a little bit long, because there is so much information, but bear with us.

All references to code sections are courtesy of the Legal Information Institute at Law.Cornell.edu.

So what is the Fair Credit Reporting Act?

The Fair Credit Reporting Act, or FCRA, is the law that requires that your credit file, commonly called a credit report be accurate.  It is found in the US Code at Title 15, Chapter 41, Subchapter III, or Title 15 US Code sections 1681 through 1681x.  Prior to the advent of this act, state and local law on defamatory statements were what controlled the dissemination of inaccurate information.  It required a showing of malicious intent, a standard which is pretty hard to ascribe to a corporation or business.

Congress passed the FCRA to protect consumers (individuals) from the credit reporting issues of the Consumer Reporting Agencies, commonly called Credit Reporting Agencies.  For brevity, we will call Consumer Reporting Agencies CRAs for this article.

Later, the FCRA was amended to add protections from actions of furnishers and users of consumer credit files.  Furnisher is not a term that is defined, but has been held to mean any entity (person or business) that provides information to the CRAs.  Users are entities (persons or businesses) that access the information stored at CRAs.

So who are the CRAs?  And who are Users? And who are Furnishers?

The BIG 3 CRAs are Equifax Information Services, LLC (Equifax), Trans Union, LLC (TransUnion) and Experian Information Solutions, lnc. (Experian). There are others, some are up and coming companies that are attempting to challenge the Big 3, like Innovis Data.  Others are “specialty” reporting agencies, like Medical Information Bureau, ChexSystems, and TeleCheck Services.

Users are companies who either you would like to do business with, or THINK you would like to do business with them.  Examples are Discover Card, American Express, Chase, CitiBank and Capital One.  They have a legitimate interest in seeing your credit file, to see if you are the kind of person who pays their bills.  They want to loan money to people who, by and large, pay their bills.  Preferably not all at once, so they can charge interest, but still, you should pay your bills.

Furnishers are the same people as users, only they are providing feedback about how well you pay them.  Examples are Discover Card, American Express, Chase, CitiBank and Capital One.  They are telling other people about their experiences with how you pay your bills- on time, late, or not at all.

So what kinds of things are violations?

The FCRA regulates most portions of the credit reporting industry.

Impermissibly accessing a person’s credit report allows, not only civil damages, similar to invasion of privacy, but in some cases, also criminal penalties.

The CRAs must maintain an accurate file on you, and their failure can lead to civil damages.

The CRAs also must investigate your complaints.  If you tell them something is wrong, they must investigate, tell the furnisher, and if the information is inaccurate or unverifiable, change or delete the information.

Furnishers must also be tasked with reporting to the CRAs your credit reporting history accurately, but, they must be notified properly before you can sue them for those damages. We recommend that you tell the furnisher what they are reporting wrong.  Tell them in detail, and preferably in writing.  YOU DO NOT HAVE A RIGHT TO SUE FOR THE FURNISHER MESSING THIS PART UP.  See 15 USC 1681s-2[c] and [d].

However, if you also notify the CRAs of the inaccuracy, they must send your dispute to the furnisher, and once they get the dispute that way, they must fix the problem, or face the possibility of being sued.  You must dispute to the CRA dispute addresses.  We suggest that you do your dispute in writing, sent by certified mail, return receipt requested.  It is not necessary to do this, but it makes proving that you notified them of the dispute easier.

What can you sue for?

FCRA is not a strict liability lawsuit, like the FDCPA or TILA or other actions.  Technical violations are NOT something you can sue for.  The FCRA is there to protect you from inaccurate information, so as numerous courts have said, you can only sue for information that is inaccurate.  But what is inaccurate?

Examples of inaccurate information are

1. Identity theft, where someone unknown to you (or maybe known to you, but you did not know they were doing this) opened an account that you did not know was being opened.
2. Mixed Credit File, where the CRAs have mixed you up with someone else, and their information is on  your credit report.  Mixed files and ID theft may be very hard to tell apart until the lawsuit has been filed, and discovery has started.
3. Reporting an account that you have paid as still owing.
4. Reaging, where they are reporting that an account that you failed to pay years ago, as a recent failure to pay.  This is particularly common when the statute of limitations has passed for the collector or creditor to sue to collect the money.  Most negative information can only be reported for 7 years, but there are exceptions.  15 U.S.C. §1681c.
5. Bankrupt account reporting, where the consumer has filed Bankruptcy, and the creditor either still, or again, reports the debt as owing or charged off, rather than discharged in Bankruptcy.  This may also be a violation of the discharge of Bankruptcy, 11 U.S.C. §524.

In each of these cases, if the information is there, it can cause damages, such as loss of ability to obtain credit on terms that YOU deserve. This can lead to other issues, which we will discuss in great detail in another blog entry.

If you have been damaged by any of these actions, you could be entitled to recover actual damages, attorney fees and costs, and in the right circumstances, punitive damages are available.  Getting to punitive damages is very hard, so we usually tell clients that punitive damages are likely to be limited, if available, in their case.

If you have been impacted by anything we mentioned here, you can make an appointment to see us.

NO FEE IN YOUR FCRA CASE UNLESS WE RECOVER!!

OUR LEGAL FEES:

The rights afforded to you, as a consumer, under the FCRA and the FDCPA means that a corporation or party who has violated your rights may ultimately be made to pay for statutory damages, actual damages, and your legal fees. Therefore, if we agree to represent you in any case, you won’t pay any attorney’s fees unless we are successful and we recover on your behalf. We are here to serve and have assisted many consumers TO enforce their legal rights. Let us try and see if we can help you too. That means you pay no fee in your case unless we recover.

Contact us by e-mail or by telephone or fax or US Mail.

You can call us: 804.673.4358

You can fax us: 804.673.4350

You can contact us by US MAIL:

Krumbein Consumer Legal Services, Inc.

1650 Willow Lawn Drive

Suite 300

Richmond, VA 23230